5 July 2008

Prashant Tamang's comment on Gorkhaland surprises many

This article is taken from http://beacononline.wordpress.com

Indian Idol comes to Buddha’s rescue

BY Sabyasachi Bandopadhyay INDIAN EXPRESS

Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee has for long been harping on the fact that the Gorkhaland impasse can only be solved through talks. Now, he has got Prashant Tamang, the “Indian Idol” from Darjeeling, for company. [Inset Prashant Tamang. Photo Archives]

Speaking to The Indian Express, Tamang said: “Gorkhaland or no Gorkhaland, the deadlock must be solved only through dialogue. There should not be any violence or bloodshed, as these do not lead us anywhere. I am a singer and not a politician. I just want that the problem is solved amicably.” Tamang, who won the singing competition last year, works for the Kolkata police.

He added that he was pained to see the Bengali-Nepali divide not only in the Hills but also in Siliguri. “This is the worst thing that could have happened,” said Tamang, who is currently in Mumbai on leave.The leaders of Gorkha Janmukti Morcha (GJM), however, accused the CPM of fomenting communal tension in Siliguri and in the Hills.

“The CPM is responsible for dividing the two communities. Both the police as well as CPM cadres had attacked the Gorkhas. We can assure that the Gorkhas will never indulge in violence and get Gorkhaland through peaceful means,” said Anmol Prasad, a member of GJM’s central committee.

113 Responses to “Indian Idol comes to Buddha’s rescue”

  1. B Lepcha Says:

    Prashant bhai’s comment on Gorkhaland issue to the Indian Express has made me very sad and disillusioned.

    ” Speaking to The Indian Express, Tamang said: “Gorkhaland or no Gorkhaland, the deadlock must be solved only through dialogue.”

    Gorkhaland or no Gorkhaland - what does he mean ????????

    Bhai you have just let down all your fellow gorkhas who supported you whole heartedly to place you up there. Good, nothing more could have been expected from you, please continue with your fame and enjoy the good things in life. In future I request you to kindly not to speak on Gorkhaland. LEAVE IT WITH US ! we will handle it….

  2. iwitness Says:

    Gorkhaland or no Gorkhaland - what does he mean ????????
    I hope he doesn’t turn out to be a bigger disappointment.

  3. YK Shrestha Says:

    Bhai Prashant, kasto udek ko kura gareko??
    mari-mari duniyabharko Gorkha haru le timilai vote diyer jitayou, kasto kura gareko? Buddhadeb ko agari kura garnu “dar” lagyo ki kaso? You would have made us proud if u had said that it is our legitimate demand. Were u worried that u will be sacked from police? Aba ta ke garne? You should not have been worried about the job.

  4. P.J. Says:

    @B. Lepcha, iwitness
    the intention of this article is to dampen the spirit and hopes to achieve a rift between the people and of course our bhai Prashant. As we all know, they weave the “words spoken” in such a way that it looses it original meaning from the “words printed” my advice is dont get emotional and more importantly be “tricked” into their ploy. There are desperate attempts of the communists!

  5. Nisha Says:

    prashant is too too polite with his words..or I am afraid to say the fear has gripped his mind should he be thrown from his job..or does he seem to have forgotten the days when all Nepalese from the world supported his cause of being idol..

    prashant bhai..Indial Idol matrai bhayera hudaina..now is the time..be a true Idol of the Gurkhas..

  6. B Lepcha Says:

    P.J.

    Maybe you could be right as the bengali’s chattupana is well known to everybody.

    But before coming to any conclusion I would request Barun to check the authenticy of this article. Was this really said or is it just another trick of the communist.

    I would appreciate if someone could contact Prashant bhai and check with him.

  7. rahul Says:

    hey guys this is authentic….this has appeared in Cal times as well. you guys really believe that prashant won because of your votes alone….you guys are bigger fools than i’d ever imagined you to be….

  8. B Lepcha Says:

    yo rahul ko tah mookhama hali dinu ni ho kosailey

  9. rahul Says:

    sachchai se kahaan bhagoge….

  10. Nisha Says:

    Dear Mr. B Lepcha..

    tapaiko wish pura mo garidinthe ni ke garnu..had he come face to face with me..

  11. Nisha Says:

    rahul..

    either speak in hindi or nepali.your words are like playing scrabbles..

    ke bhaneko you..sachchai se kahaan bhagoge..? kis bhagode ki baat kar rahe ho..

    ofcourse I accept the truth…Prashant wont not only coz whole of the Nepalese were united..but I was always happy to know that our Indian brother and sisters joined hands to bring him to that level..

  12. P.J. Says:

    @rahul
    are you implying that since the news was also published in cal hence it can be deemed authentic? Duh! Such News are published all over the world, didnt you know, mr marketing manager? Every once in a while we come across news as “Subash C. Bhosh, Elvis Presley are still alive”, i saw one report in cal once, authentic? Imagination is not the only deficiency that you suffer from as your comments clearly reflects. Get a life!

  13. B Lepcha Says:

    P.J. you deserve a toast for that “Cheers mate - keep it rolling”

  14. B Lepcha Says:

    Nishaji sacchai nai yo bongs haru ko kura sunera yesto rees utcha ki khai ke bhannu…agadi bha pani kagaz jasto chyati dine thiye..

  15. Nisha Says:

    Dear Mr. B. Lepcha..

    now! now you sound like one of my dear and darling jojo..Swaroop Chamling..and again yet another brother of mine..YK Shrestha..

    you are absolute correct, I guess all Gurkhas are on right track..when again the bongs force us to get in their stupid ways of abusement and insults..!!!

    ke garnu…tato tato ris!! ka jhaarnu jhaarnu huncha..!!

  16. YK Shrestha Says:

    rahul Says:
    July 3, 2008 at 2:58 pm
    hey guys this is authentic….this has appeared in Cal times as well. you guys really believe that prashant won because of your votes alone….you guys are bigger fools than i’d ever imagined you to be….

    Rahul, u claim to be GM(East) of Radio Mirchi and write things which are not digestable. Yes,Prashant won because of our votes. You guys voted for Amit Paul just because he is a bengali even though he was from other state. If you really cared for Gorkhas, you would have voted for Prashant as he is/was from West Bengal. Have heart man!!

  17. P.J. Says:

    @Nisha, B. lepcha
    “Aru ley goo khayo bhandai ma hami ley pani goo khannu hundai na”
    therefore, just refrain from generalising the entire community, as these are just the rotten ones, all communities have a few right? Do not bring yourself at the level of these imbeciles!
    Keep the faith!

  18. Nisha Says:

    hoina PJ..hamilai goo khanu ta patakkai aaundaina…EET KA JAWAF PATTHAR PO TA! thats what we are giving him…

    have you noticed..when these bongs call us by all nasty names..no comments pass by to put a stop at it..but when we reply back in their own nasty way..somebody always tried to criticize the way we are commenting..i am a new comer at this blog…but I have seen previous postings all nonsense.and which just boils my blood..
    abo you only tell me ta..can we tolerate such humiliation!!??

  19. Nisha Says:

    YK Dai..you served Rahul right..?? bhainkar hunu po khojda raicha..!!

  20. P.J. Says:

    B. Lepcha jiu,
    after Gorkhaland is formed, “tongba & dried beef” ko celebration garnu parcha hai? Till then keep the faith!

  21. YK Shrestha Says:

    tyo jhegne afai lai bhayankar intellectual mancha.darjeeling ma pareko hare. heru, hamile you gorkhali bhasa me lekheko tyasle bujhcha ki bujhdaina!!

  22. YK Shrestha Says:

    PJ,

    Count me in. maile ta kasam khayeko chu, bhakku mater raatbhari chowrasta ma ulti gardai sutchu :-)

  23. Nisha Says:

    PJ and YK Shrestha daju..

    hunu ta pothi baasnu hudaina hai..but your get together just tempted me..”malai pani include garnus nai tyo tongba ra dried beef ko bhoj ma..abo party shabda use garnu hudaina..thet gorkhali bhaasha ma bhoj bhater bhacha..anyway,baru mo pani jaad liyera aaune chu..ha ha!

  24. Nisha Says:

    ani yam daju..

    chyaa! ulti garne kura nagarnus hai..maile bharkhar khaaja khako..kasto malai po ulti aaula aaula jastai bhayo..tapaiko kura sunera..

  25. Nisha Says:

    ani euta daami item left out bhayo hai..can i get that included..sungur ko khutta ko achaar…ammmaamam! daami huncha hai..?? lets celebrate gorkhalands victory this way!

    HAIL GORKHALAND!! JAI FOR THE NEPALESE!

  26. YK Shrestha Says:

    Malai sungur ko khuta ko achar ko yaad nadilau. mari janchu mata samjher.

  27. Nisha Says:

    okay! then its done..when Gorkhaland is a free state..I shall be there and cook that delicious thing for you..just be sure not to puke!!!

    we do have a good sense of humor right.? hope my spelling is correct..otherwise Rahul could pop his head and tell me to go for the correction..but hey no! I have given him his day of work..ha ha!

  28. P.J. Says:

    Nisha
    we should not tolerate such communal comments from these stooges. Had they any good arguments, they would have talked about it, but by their comments, it clearly shows that they have mouths bigger than their heads and a heart of a rat. But at the same time, we have friends and families in their community too, atleast for their sake we should respect the bengali community haina ruh?
    As for the bhoj, how can we leave a member of our family, you are in it ni, goes without saying. One more thing try to get some “aila” la? ;-) Yk da, the deal is on hai!

  29. pseude Says:

    HELLO, who’s making the communal comments here? All of you are having a good time mocking everything about Bengalis in this blog. Rahul made one comment, but you guys replied with a fullisade of abuses, much of it in Nepali. Anyways, if you get your rotten pleasure from this pastime, its worth you guys.

  30. pseude Says:

    Keep up your good job with the abuses. We are reading every word of these and we dont want to forget.

  31. YK Shrestha Says:

    Pseude, again u seem to have off day. If you have some gorkha friend (do u have any??), then have it translated and get the meaning. We have not abused bengali friends, we are just having fun among ourselves.
    When ur fraternity makes communal remarks, u go on defending them and when some of our folks do, then u have a problem.

  32. P.J. Says:

    @pseude
    welcome back!
    would you be so kind to point out, what abuses were said in Nepali language against the bengali community?

  33. B Lepcha Says:

    Pseude…my my you seem to be going pale and blue with hatred and anger towards Gorkhas eh? Wouldnt do you any good man…..

    So by now you must have understood Newtons 3rd law (If you don’t remember let me recap it for you “EVERY ACTION HAS AN EQUAL AN OPPOSTIE REACTION” So bandhu tell your people to think before they comment anything against us Gorkhas and that goes to you as well.

    We believe in REPAYING IN FULL so next time you try to mess with a Gorkha you might not know what hit you..So becareful bandhu because the Bongs days are numbered now.

  34. tatu Says:

    congratulations prashant tamang, you proofed, you are a true indian idol through your thoughts and speech. you are a true soldiers. dont afraid ,whole country with you. and convince bimal/roshan violance brings nothing.

  35. YK Shrestha Says:

    Tatu, now you see Prashant as a true Indian,where were you when he needed ur votes? All your votes went to Amit Paul (just bcoz he is a bengali) from a different state.

  36. B Lepcha Says:

    Now how many of these do we have here…first it was Reta now this Tatu.

  37. darjeeling Says:

    I voted for you prashant and today you really made me proud, you gave your views without being afraid of the GJM, u have proved your r a true brave Gorkha!!

  38. YK Shrestha Says:

    Aiya, kahabata aayo yo nakkali Darjeeling feri???

  39. tatu Says:

    dear shrestha, dont generalize, i have not only cast my vote , i have collected money from my office staff for him. because he is belongs to my dist. but, if i came to that bimal/roshan utilized this issue in a communal angel, like you . i might be refrained to do so.

  40. YK Shrestha Says:

    Hard to believe that Tatu. Don’t give me that, even your Ashok Bhattacharya campaigned for Amit Paul.

  41. P.J. Says:

    There seems to be a lot fakes here adopting Gorkha names trying to mislead ppl which evidently they are not, as if anyone would give them the importance of coming after them he they used their real names hai. Pathetic! Where is pseude? Or is he still getting it translated?

  42. tatu Says:

    this is the problem of you people mr shrestha and p.j. you think all are like you.

  43. P.J. Says:

    @tatu
    didnt quite get your point. Can you elaborate pls?

  44. tatu Says:

    if you not get my point, i am sorry. pl read all the blogs from one to one.hope you will understand.

  45. Shlomo Yitzak Says:

    Mr. Shrestha,

    Without too much of orientation about the Nepalis of the hills of Darjeeling it comes easy for any visitor from another Asian country in the Middle East as where I am from to read into your extreme feverish attitude problem. Your lack of knowledge of history has produced a Brat out of you and not a so-called die hard Nepali you are trying to prove yourself to be. I do not even believe that you are a Nepali or Gorkhali for all that matters. You guys are experts in playing with semantics and going nowhere. You size up people just by reading one or two lines written by some with whom you do not agree. You are drowning in your own brat-itude because you cannot see beyond the ranges and peaks that physically encircle you. Once this youth in you comes to terms with the pains of rejection and old age you will see things differently. How naive of you to assume that all those Gorkhas who do not agree with you are faking Gorkha names. How much stranger it is that an Israeli from the Israeli Army on vacation and passionate tours to India several times over the last 35 years need to borrow names from a goof like you. How low is your low? How mentally arrested you have become. You guys are feasting on labelling weaker communicative people as retards, calling Bengalis Bongs and yet retaining Nepalis to be Gorkhas with due respect. Who are you kidding?

  46. RAJA Says:

    dear all friends,
    Please write in Hindi or English as I cant understand your language. Please……

    nisha ji again i want to fight with you….. why you are writting that every nepalies had put their effeort to make Prasant a Indian Idol???

    Nisha ji I have also given so many sms votes for Prasant on that time now you peoples are saying that prasant have won only because of nepali vote from all over world!!!!

    I am so shocked……then why the small cute girl from darjeeling could not make her semifinal debut in saregama pa of STAR TV??? why the nepalies from whole world did not put their effort behind her????

    strange!!!!

  47. RAJA Says:

    dear all friends,
    Please write in Hindi or English as I cant understand your language. Please……

    nisha ji again i want to fight with you….. why you are writting that every nepalies had put their effeort to make Prasant a Indian Idol???

    Nisha ji I have also given so many sms votes for Prasant on that time now you peoples are saying that prasant have won only because of nepali vote from all over world!!!!

    I am so shocked……then why the small cute girl from darjeeling could not make her semifinal debut in saregama pa of STAR TV??? why the nepalies from whole world did not put their effort behind her????

    strange!!!!

    Raja
    east Hartfort, CT
    USA

  48. aardee Says:

    Yitzak,..you write well…continue, but refrain from instigating and calling names to visitors on this blog.

    And I agree with you we must learn to respect each other…
    Hum ko mann ki shakti dena…
    mann vijay karein…
    doosron ki JAI se pehle
    khud ko Jai karein…
    Better still if we are into Gandhi vadi…
    Vaishnav jan toh te ne kahiye
    je pir parayi jaaniye…

    But definitely Prashant Tamang should have shown more spine and said Gorkhaland will happen and for that all parties must have an open dialogue.

  49. Relay Says:

    Was the selection of this guy ( Tamang ? ) as Indian Idol somehow “fixed” by enthusiastic Gurkhas flooding the phone lines with votes ? I have seen reports somewhere that before the selection event, quite a few road blocks were set up on the way to Darjeeling to demand contributions from non Gurkhas / Tourists so as to raise money for phone calls.

    Do the phone companies have record of where the calls to the Indian Idol selectors originated from ? Wonder if that money also helped boost the current agitation.

    Enthusiasm, Racism are but steps towards Fascism. Can India afford to create within itself a nucleus of race based exclusivity and hate - mongering that borders on Fascism ? Is not one Kashmir enough ?

    Will Barun Roy, who champions Gurkhaland, investigate and report on this matter ?

  50. Y Pradhan Says:

    Sala Hamro paisa le jeetcha anta hamro nai cause lai tyesto bhancha???

    @ Tatu
    You say you collected money to vote for Prashant???
    How much???

    My Phone bill for that month was Rs. 17000,and I don’t even use land lines because of cell phones Did you collect that much???
    There were ppl who donated in Lakhs to vote for that guy, Did you collect that much??
    I have seen coolies donate Rs. 10-20 every day from their daily wages, and they earn so little.
    And this happened not only in Darj but also in Sikkim and other places where nepalis are there.
    I am not denying the facts that non nepalis didn’t support him but how many vots 1-2 votes per week, and the Bengalis supported Amit Paul…its a known fact. So shut ur mouth.

    @Relay
    Dude If you don’t know then shut up ok.
    The prilims were not vote rounds infact judges selected the contestent so how can the event you mentiond happen before selection event???? I appreciate intellegent talk not blabbering.
    And what ever money was collected was donated on free will.
    No body forced ppl to vote prashant….Infact I know lots of Nepali who voted Amit Paul.
    Do you know Nepalis were beaten in Shillong and were forced to vote Amit paul???
    Do you know that Khasi Ppl stopped Nepalis on the way and checked sent items from their cell phones to check who they voted???
    OH YES! FOR THAT REPORT, YOU CAN ROLL IT AND SHOVE IT UP UR “YOU KNOW WHERE”!

    @ RAJA

    The girl did not make it to the finals because the craze was what it was during Prashant’s time. Ppl did vote but not the way they did for Prashant because for prashant was the first Nepali to reach to that stage of any reality show.

    Ho, abo awaj nai heryo bhane ta aru ramro ramro bhag line haru thiyo ni, prashant le kasari jityo??? Hamro Vote le.

    Pahila Darban ko luga lagayera ayo, abo yo??? Uslai pani SG jastai nai garnu parcha hola.

  51. RAJA Says:

    hey y pradahan,
    yaar it’s great to hear from you…..hey are you trying to say that you have given vote more than 10000 votes alone for Prasant????

    If so the you peoples have cheated other contestant …you cant give vote like that….i had given vote to prasant as he was looking so innocent….not because of his voice….

    by d way it’s not the question of how many votes you have sent for him or me….

    if KHASIYAS peoples have resisting you peoples in meghalaya then it was very bad.

    But we all should vote 1 or 2 not thousands otherwise what’s the need of these kind of reality show…..where candidate is already selected by the statehood/race/etc etc…

  52. RAJA Says:

    Mr.Y Pradhan,

    can you please write what you have written in Hindi or English…..as i dont know nepali…

  53. Y Pradhan Says:

    Raja,

    What I wrote in Nepali was not meant for you.
    And as far as cheating is concerned there was no restriction on how many vots can on vote. its not a Parliamentry election which said 1 vote per person. It said keep on voting for your favorite constant and that was done.

  54. kaushik Says:

    okie dear ,
    understood….

  55. YK Shrestha Says:

    (Shlomo Yitzak Says:
    July 3, 2008 at 6:34 pm
    Mr. Shrestha,

    Without too much of orientation about the Nepalis of the hills of Darjeeling it comes easy for any visitor from another Asian country in the Middle East as where I am from to read into your extreme feverish attitude problem. Your lack of knowledge of history has produced a Brat out of you and not a so-called die hard Nepali you are trying to prove yourself to be. I do not even believe that you are a Nepali or Gorkhali for all that matters. You guys are experts in playing with semantics and going nowhere. You size up people just by reading one or two lines written by some with whom you do not agree. You are drowning in your own brat-itude because you cannot see beyond the ranges and peaks that physically encircle you. Once this youth in you comes to terms with the pains of rejection and old age you will see things differently. How naive of you to assume that all those Gorkhas who do not agree with you are faking Gorkha names. How much stranger it is that an Israeli from the Israeli Army on vacation and passionate tours to India several times over the last 35 years need to borrow names from a goof like you. How low is your low? How mentally arrested you have become. You guys are feasting on labelling weaker communicative people as retards, calling Bengalis Bongs and yet retaining Nepalis to be Gorkhas with due respect. Who are you kidding?)
    ===========================================================================================

    Come on Shlomo Yitttzak, whoever u r. If you are truly an Israeli, why don’t u go and fight the Palestines? I have always been a supporter of Israel as I’m a Christian and I have this desire to walk down the path that Jesus had walked. Whom are you trying to fool by borrowing that Jewish name? The way u r writing reflects a bengali person. Either you have run away from Israel from fear of defending your borders against the Palestines and have been here in India for too long to know everything about Darjeeling or you are a fake. If you are a true Jew, then I salute you for your views, because we do not necessarily believe that every non-bengali would believe with our views. If you are a true Israeli, then you can take my mail id and contact no from the moderator and let’s have a chat brother.
    I’m not a youth like you, I’m well past 48 years, so don’t give me lessons.

  56. YK Shrestha Says:

    (Relay Says:
    July 3, 2008 at 8:57 pm
    Was the selection of this guy ( Tamang ? ) as Indian Idol somehow “fixed” by enthusiastic Gurkhas flooding the phone lines with votes ? I have seen reports somewhere that before the selection event, quite a few road blocks were set up on the way to Darjeeling to demand contributions from non Gurkhas / Tourists so as to raise money for phone calls.

    Do the phone companies have record of where the calls to the Indian Idol selectors originated from ? Wonder if that money also helped boost the current agitation.

    Enthusiasm, Racism are but steps towards Fascism. Can India afford to create within itself a nucleus of race based exclusivity and hate - mongering that borders on Fascism ? Is not one Kashmir enough ?

    Will Barun Roy, who champions Gurkhaland, investigate and report on this matter ?)

    Didn’t the supporters of Amit Paul in Meghalaya (those khasis who have been butting ur guys all the time, I wonder what happened to them that time) bar the Gorkhas from voting? The DG of Shillong is a Gorkha, but he played a non-partisan and neutral role, but the chief secy of Meghalay Govt (who happens to be a bengali) had the cheek to call upon the WB govt. to support Amit Paul. The bengali MLA of Meghalaya donated 1 crore for voting. Who is more racist, communal? Do u have any answer??

  57. Nisha Says:

    Dear dear Raja,

    I accept the truth that I had said all Nepalese were united for the cause of Prashant..but why did you not notice the lines to be followed..get your eyes checked up dude!!! re-read my lines again…
    (ofcourse I accept the truth…Prashant wont not only coz whole of the Nepalese were united..but I was always happy to know that our Indian brother and sisters joined hands to bring him to that level..)

    i am sick and really sick of you guys..!!

  58. Nisha Says:

    Tatu and Pseudo..(wish they could come with their real names) can only see the fault of the brave Gurkhas..!!! stop acting like HYPOCRITES..!!!

  59. Nisha Says:

    Hi Pseudo..

    what made you think we were abusing you guys? If so many Nepalese can speak and read your bong language..why dont you too try to read our language..or before you start getting any wrong notions about our comments..get it translated..for free!!

    ufff!!! its so suffocating here…!!!

  60. Nisha Says:

    HI PJ..

    yes, I shall definitely get the finest AAILA..for you..!!

  61. Kamaane kanchha Says:

    A trivia:
    Cute li’l Prakriti Giri dint win because when the top 2 had to be selected out of 3, selection process was altered!
    The voting comprised of 50% Judges’ vote and 50% public’s. Besides, one telephone number could vote only once in 30 minutes.
    Simply to say, Sa Re Ga Ma was scared as hell of Gorkhas’ might! :) And used all the measures to bar us from making another winner!
    I know the other contestants were better than Prakriti and deserved to go to finals, but same was the case in Indian Idol, wasn’t it?
    Yet, our Prashant bhai won, what that sums up to is, we have the will and attitude to defy the assumptions and come out victorious!
    And we’ll do it again!
    Haami aru kehi jaandainau, Gorkhaland haami liyera ni chhaadchau!

  62. Nisha Says:

    shyaabash kamaane kancha..(kind of proud with this name of yours…ek dam typical NERPALI lagyo)

    balla nepali kancha boleko jastai lagyo…

  63. Nisha Says:

    shyaabash kamaane kancha..(kind of proud with this name of yours…ek dam typical NEPALI lagyo)

    balla nepali kancha boleko jastai lagyo…

  64. Relay Says:

    Well my worst suspicions seem to have come true. Prashant Tamang won because his Gurkha supporters voted more than once. And posters on this BB ( e,g. Mr. Shrestha ) seem to be damn proud to have done so ! I don’t think that the organizers of Indian Idol were expecting quite that. Voting like that would be considered as CHEATING anywhere else in the world. This shows that the Gurkhas are a bunch of law - breaking hooligans with no respect for democratic norms. Letting these fascist thugs have a state of their own would be as big a blunder as dealing with the Kashmiri Moslems or mad dogs in a humane way.

  65. Nisha Says:

    Relay..you HOODLUM!!

    Your worst suspicions indeed has come out true..coz you can only think of the worst..!! If the Gurkhas and all the Nepalese including our Indian friends have voted for Prashant several times..then in parallel goes the voting for Amit Paul for whom you have voted more than once..
    c’mon yaar! dont talk stupidly here! everyone knows the truth..!! bacche logo ko class de rakha samjha hai kya..!!??

    Reality show mein to bahut cheating hoti hai..ye tumko aaj pata chala..YOU OLD TUBELIGHT..!!! dimaag mein bhoosa bhara hai kya..???!!!

    calling us thugs and dogs..???!! you scoundrel..!!!

    SORRY MR. RAMANENDU GHOSH AND BARUN ROY..!! THIS GUY STARTED FIRST..

  66. B Lepcha Says:

    Barun deleting the word “bongs” from my comment was not a nice thing to do. Couldn’t really understand bro’.

    HAIL GORKHAS HAIL GORKHALAND

  67. Nisha Says:

    HO RA MR B LEPCHA..!!

    DID BARUN ACTUALLY DELETED THE WORD BONG..??

    I HOPE HE DELETED THE WORD UGLY WHERE TATU HAD USED BEFORE..UGLY KHUKURI BHANEKO THIYO NI…AND MORE TO BE DELETED..GOD! KATI WOTA DELETE GARNE RA..MALAI PO PURA PASINA AYO..!!

    HAIL GORKHALAND..VEER NEPALIES!

  68. PPA Says:

    Relay -
    Naive or Pretending?

    Anywhere else in the world? where else are you talking about? This is the format of the game.

    rest of your post is as idiotic as you so, its not possible to react to it. You need some serious growing up to do man / woman. You seem quite clueless as to what is happening around you so, it would help to read before you write - hear before you speak and eat before you regurgitate what you are unable to stomach.

  69. Nisha Says:

    HA HA HA HA! CAN’T HELP MYSELF..!!!

  70. Mohammad Says:

    Relay

    “Letting these fascist thugs have a state of their own would be as big a blunder as dealing with the Kashmiri Moslems or mad dogs in a humane way”.

    I think you have just made the biggest blunder of your life.

  71. Mohammad Says:

    Nishaji honi it was deleted, ahiley hereko tah pura comment nai delete gari diyecha. bolnu bhayena tuppi rahena.

  72. Kamaane kanchha Says:

    @relay
    Brother, seems you lack the basic understanding needed to sustain your standard thought-process. What did you just say? “Voting like that would be considered as CHEATING anywhere else in the world.” Who says so? Is it something that we missed while voting? I dint know bulk voting with your own money was cheating! Thank you for enlightening moron!
    “This shows that the Gorkhas are a bunch of law - breaking hooligans with no respect for democratic norms.” -The Indian govt. knows, the IT companies set up in Salt Lake Sector 5 knows, who is law-breaking hooligans! Some minister falls sick and you guys call for bandhs! and you call us Law breaking hooligans, what an irony!! The very reason behind top IT companies not coming to Kolkata is your kind has no respect for them, their work culture. How long will you bask in the glory of Netaji Subash and Gurudev Rabindranath Tagore?
    “Letting these fascist thugs have a state of their own would be as big a blunder as dealing with the Kashmiri Moslems or mad dogs in a humane way.” - Now you only tell me who is fascist! :) You already are black as a crow(my assumption), please don’t sound like one(my observation)!
    It might or might not be a blunder(you think so) to give us what we rightfully possess, but it has been a bigger blunder to be ruled by West Bengal Govt.
    Thank but no thanks, we have had enough!

    Yours acrimoniously
    Kamaane Kanchha

  73. Nisha Says:

    HI Mohammad…

    does that mean..mero pani comments haru delete bhayo ta..how rude!!?? but ke cha ra..padne le padisakyo..bujhne le bujhisakyo..

  74. B Lepcha Says:

    Kamaane Kanchhaji very true !

    I hope Relay and other bongs ooooopsss sorry I mean bengalis have got the message LOUD AND CLEAR.

  75. YK Shrestha Says:

    ( Relay Says:
    July 4, 2008 at 12:29 pm
    Well my worst suspicions seem to have come true. Prashant Tamang won because his Gurkha supporters voted more than once. And posters on this BB ( e,g. Mr. Shrestha ) seem to be damn proud to have done so ! I don’t think that the organizers of Indian Idol were expecting quite that. Voting like that would be considered as CHEATING anywhere else in the world. This shows that the Gurkhas are a bunch of law - breaking hooligans with no respect for democratic norms. Letting these fascist thugs have a state of their own would be as big a blunder as dealing with the Kashmiri Moslems or mad dogs in a humane way.)

    Relay,you ass (donkey), we voted coz we wanted and that was allowed. U should have voted if u wanted Emon or Amit to win. Oh, oh, let the Kashmiris hear what u r saying and you had it!!

  76. Nisha Says:

    I WISH A KASHMIRI BLOGGER WOULD SEE HIS POSTING..!!

  77. B Lepcha Says:

    Nishaji what more can we expect from these bongs oooops sorry Bengalis. If a kasmiri sees @Relay’s posting than the ekla chalo party is gone for a toss.

  78. Nisha Says:

    Mr. B. Lepcha..dherai bongs bongs nabhaniranus hai..you will get blacklisted like me! ha ha! afulai nai BANDIT QUEEN jasto lagirakocha..

  79. B Lepcha Says:

    Nishaji bhannuh tah mann lagdai nah ni tarah ke garney yini haru ko attitude ani hatred hami tarfa dekhera bhani pathai halchu. Yesto kukure behura huncha yini haru ko bhanera kahiley socheko thiyena.

    Yo posting pani delete garidinehola ni abo…’B’ party le bujena bhanera.

    Bhanda ‘B’ party chahi hamro code word ho la bujnu bhayo hola ni…

    Malai tah euta hamro purano nepali geet po yaad ayo ” Mailey bolnai bhanera” la la la la al al he ehe eheehehhe

  80. Sachin Says:

    Please do not go word by word with what Prashant has “SAID”.

    Its a movement, its a strive. 2010 is not a realistic goal at least in my point of view.

    We need at least 50 Member of Parliament to vouch this idea, educated leaders to debate for us.

    Few of the things. Many more. We all know…..

  81. Nisha Says:

    Mr. B. Lepcha..ramro sita bujhe tyo B code..dimaag ma ghusaayera rakheko chu….aaaa! delete gare pani garos..bhanne kura ta bhani ta halyo ni hoina? abo B use garda ta pheri malai warning aaundaina hola ni…!!? school ma warnings haru bheteko jastai lagyo..!!! but darlagena..!!

  82. B Lepcha Says:

    Nishaji you have spoken like a true Gorkha woman.

  83. Nisha Says:

    Oh Mr. B Lepcha..

    you are still here…!??

    malai ta chitta bujhena office ma last hereko yo blog..so again ghar ma aayera check gareko ta mero lagi ta laskarey raicha B’s haruko comment…eklai bhaye pani jati sakcha didaichu answer..

    mo Nepal ma chu harey..so I am no Indian bhanda raicha..kasto stupid hai..we are fighting for our Identity as Gurkhas..as Nepalese..and here they are acting like sick parrots..!!

  84. thebengali Says:

    nisha

    fighting for nepali and gurkha identity

    huh

  85. thebengali Says:

    nisha

    fighting for nepali and gurkha identity

    huh!

  86. jwalahang Says:

    yah….u’ve already been kicked out of BANGLAESH..and u ‘ll are going to meet the same fate here.

  87. jwalahang Says:

    ami tumarke LAJJA diechhe…! para sona karo !

  88. Nisha Says:

    oh yes! i fight for my gurkha and nepalese identity? what the f**k do you dare to fight for?

    didnt u have enough of ROSHOGOLLAS today…

  89. Nisha Says:

    help!!! The Bengali is having a terrible nightmare..!! can anyone help me look for a smelly shoes..or socks..so that I can let him smell that..!! hes fainting buddies..!!

  90. jwalahang Says:

    yeah… his foreign minister Pranab babu has been successful in pursuading the Bangladesh govt to export hilsa.

  91. Nisha Says:

    oh god! The bengali has gone to coma..!! but i swear I shall revive him anyhow..coz I need him on Sunday too..i like getting his butt kicked..!!

    chow darling..!! sayonara…see ya on Sunday….I am ready to face your terrible face..!!

  92. thebengali Says:

    at least we have the hilsa fish and rosogolla. we are proud of it

    what do you have- in nepal.

    JAI BANGA, JAI BHARAT

  93. thebengali Says:

    and i cant understant why it hurts when i call you foreigners. true indians dont car. is it because of you dubious identity

  94. jwalahang Says:

    that’s because you have been kicked out by the Bangladeshis…

  95. jwalahang Says:

    ur whole sense doesn’t function properly because of the trauma…

  96. Nisha Says:

    what do we eat in Nepal…you stupid! we eat all types of foods..from Indian, continental cuisine..Japanese, Korean..lols!
    ufff!!! macch ki durgandh aaa rahi hai…
    better i go! before this smell makes me puke..yuukkkk!!!

  97. jwalahang Says:

    c.. the bengali..u must know the truth…West Bengal is there because of the Hills….its tea,its timber, its tourism,its hydro-power.Otherwise u place would have been like CONGO….

  98. thebengali Says:

    well nisha you have only one portal of entry and exit. i know your shit is the same as your vomit.

    and the reason you eat continental, japanese etc is because you dont have your own cuisine.

    we are proud of ours

    Jai Banga

  99. B Lepcha Says:

    thebongoli we have goondrook, kinema and dalley khorsani to rub it in your ass.

  100. B Lepcha Says:

    thebengali you talk about cuisine…ha ha rasgollas is that all you have in the menu…my foot.

  101. Sidanth Chhetri Says:

    “thebengali” dude you should never leave remarks in places where all you’d get in return is curses and foul-mouthing, that would be a mouthful..keep that in mind SON!! as far as talking about your stereotypical thinking of us, our people, our cuisine, we don’t give a shit!! you’re at the wrong place buddy, join your group of phattus (stereotypical viewpoint of the senseless “Bengalis” like yourself by an Average Indian) at the Amar ‘Gay’ Bangla group and suck some “pop-sickles” will you… while you’re at it..i’m not saying all Bengalis are bad, most of them are good, they believe in fairness, equality and think logically and we respect those people…
    “we” were never a part of your state….read history, our “to be state” was actually annexed by your state…and yes our meatballs are dry would you lick it wet??

    JAI GORKHALAND!! JAI BHARAT!!!

  102. RAJA Says:

    sidhand Chetri,
    I think you should read histry first…..darjeeling was a part of Sikkim it was never a separate state….okie….I think you peoples should start demand to add darjeeling with sikkim …. your demand for separate GL state is vauge and invalid….

  103. Relay Says:

    MESSAGE TO ALL THE LEPCHAS & BHUTIAS OF DARJEELING, KALIMPONG & SIKKIM

    Please write letters to Political Leaders in Delhi about how the Gurkhas from Nepal STOLE your land and have turned you into Second Class Citizens in your own homeland of Darjeeling & Sikkim.

    You will have our complete support ( including financial ) if you would like to go to Delhi and make your complaints to the Politicians there in person.

    Its time to expose the Gurkha WOLVES in Sheeps clothing

  104. RAJA Says:

    Dear Mr. Barun,
    Your Himalayan Beacon’s (blogger room) will soon loose its publicity if peoples use such abusive and absurd words to each others….

    I think some fellows among us is lack of proper education…..they dont know how to respect each others community….

    Shame on you all

  105. RAJA Says:

    history….not histry…it was a typing mistake …i am sorry

  106. thebengali Says:

    i fully support the idea of Relay. All lepchas need to unite against the nepalis for their matribhumi. We will only talk to the sons of the soil.

    JAI BANGA, JAI LEPCHABHUMI

    JAI BHARAT

  107. thebengali Says:

    thebengali” dude you should never leave remarks in places where all you’d get in return is curses and foul-mouthing, that would be a mouthful..keep that in mind SON!! as far as talking about your stereotypical thinking of us, our people, our cuisine, we don’t give a shit!! you’re at the wrong place buddy, join your group of phattus (stereotypical viewpoint of the senseless “Bengalis” like yourself by an Average Indian) at the Amar ‘Gay’ Bangla group and suck some “pop-sickles” will you… while you’re at it..i’m not saying all Bengalis are bad, most of them are good, they believe in fairness, equality and think logically and we respect those people…
    “we” were never a part of your state….read history, our “to be state” was actually annexed by your state…and yes our meatballs are dry would you lick it wet??

    JAI GORKHALAND!! JAI BHARAT!!!

    SIDHANT

    these comments clearly reflects your upbringing and parentage

    and i know where you get your history lessons from - from the wikipedia.

  108. Sidanth Chhetri Says:

    The hatred is brewing, “thebengali” sorry to disappoint you I had a great upbringing, my mom and dad taught me well and I’m doing pretty good, Its so disappointing to see you not understanding the youth opening their eyes and seeing and understanding what is happening, now you’re trying to break us down, with your filthy policy of separating our people…the divide and rule policy…. its just “deep south craters (in the human body)..hope i framed it well to hide obscenity in my language for your discretion…that make me want to abuse you ;) we can go all out son…we can go on and on…we want a separate state as we have been ignored for long. now since we’re getting National and International media coverage regarding this issue, by the way i’m based in the UK, brought up in Kalimpong, your state govt. wants to utilize all its SOS policies of all sorts of crash courses to ensure development in our region which it had no concern for such a long time, only ensuring its dogs in the DGHC were happily fed, we were fooled once, we can’t be fooled twice, we’re more Nation concerned than you are SIR!! We have our boys fighting for ‘our nation’ in the borders sacrificing their lives!!!! If you still don’t get it go on finish that ‘pop-sickle’…NO HARD FEELINGS TO MY OTHER BENGALI BROTHERS..THIS DUDE HAS IT COMING..SUPPORT THIS MOVEMENT AND HELP OUR PEOPLE GROW”

    SID O

    Jai Hind, Jai Gorkhaland.

  109. Sidanth Chhetri Says:

    and by the way Raja i guess i didn’t clearly write in english or you didn’t get it!!! I never mentioned Darjeeling to be a separate state before i said a would be state!!!
    ke dada bangla katha te lekhte hobe na ki :D

  110. Sidanth Chhetri Says:

    Dear Mr. Barun Roy,

    Sir, I have been following your work for a long time and I know you may have made a lot of enemies within a certain section (not all) within your community but Sir you sure have gained a lot of respect and love from all of “us”, you are being fair, just minded and speaking for us, as per what you observe in the hills. Wanted to say Thank You, Sincerely!!!

    Sidanth Chhetri,
    Edinburgh.

  111. whatever... Says:

    yo “thebengali” chai kay ho.. battery lay pakako aap josto.. abnormal kura matrai garcha ta..
    and he’s in almost all of the posts here, badmouthing our community like there was no tomorrow..

  112. Sidanth Chhetri Says:

    due apologies to my previous post no 108. I meant GNLF not DGHC…
    sincerely

  113. nepdai Says:

    Whatever,

    battery le pakako aap jasto re? haha..hasayo.

    Some of them are repeating the same thing again and again that’s why I stopped commenting here long time ago. I believe in healthy discussion not in a baseless argument.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

To all my fellow brothers and sisters in India. This communal hatred is deeply saddening. Intense hatred will land you nowhere...will only eat/ruin you. Wake up! Open your heart to love,understanding and kindness of one another.

Anonymous said...

Hami ek hau , this was proved by prashant's indian idol, , people in many parts of india and abroad proved this during indian idol, that even after such a long stay away from each other we are the same, that proves the cultural integrity among ourselfs. Interestingly gorkhas people in shillong were risking themselves to vote for prasant, though amit was a better singer and choice for them.

But one thing: hami dui huna pani samay lagdaina bhaney kura ghising le dekhayo, ani nepal ma ailako situation le pani tastai nai prove gairdai cha aru anta ma Prashant bhai le pani tai nai prove garya.

One request Prasant you being an internatition figure could be one of our cultural ambassador on today's context and for the fight of gorkhaland. I rather say Gorkhibhumi